Here is a complete IHP 420 Module 4 privacy assignment analyzing five requests for a trauma patient's information under the HIPAA Privacy Rule and state reporting law, with a disclosure table, the minimum necessary standard, the ethical basis and staff guidance. Searches like "ihp 420 module 4 assignment", "ihp420 module 4 confidentiality and privacy assignment" and "ihp 420 module 4 example" land here.
The IHP 420 Module 4 example, in full
Five Requests in One Day: Applying the HIPAA Privacy Rule to Disclosures About a Gunshot Wound Patient
[Student Name]
Southern New Hampshire University
IHP 420: Ethical and Legal Considerations of Healthcare
Module Four Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Five Requests in One Day: Applying the HIPAA Privacy Rule to Disclosures About a Gunshot Wound Patient
The Scenario and the General Rule
Mr. Reyes, a composite 24-year-old warehouse worker, was brought to a composite Level II trauma center with a gunshot wound to the thigh and admitted after surgery. He is awake and able to make decisions. Within 12 hours, five people asked about him. The general rule is that a covered entity may not use or disclose protected health information except as the Privacy Rule permits or requires, or as the patient authorizes (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights [OCR], n.d.-a). Each request must therefore be matched to a specific permission. Privacy law in a hospital is less a single wall than a set of narrow doors, each opening only for a stated purpose and a stated amount of information.
Summary of Requests and Decisions
The table summarizes each request, the governing provision and the decision.
Table 1
Five Requests and the Rules That Govern Them
| Requester | Governing provision | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Police detective at the bedside | Disclosures required by law (state gunshot reporting) and limited law enforcement disclosures | Report required facts; further details only with the patient's agreement or another specific permission |
| Girlfriend by phone | Disclosures to persons involved in care, with the patient's opportunity to agree or object | Ask the patient; share only what he permits |
| Employer | No permission applies without authorization | Decline; the patient may provide a work note himself |
| Television reporter | Facility directory, only if the patient did not opt out and only if the requester asks by name | Patient opted out of the directory; confirm nothing |
| Mother at the front desk | Persons involved in care, subject to the patient's wishes | Ask the patient; he agrees to his mother knowing his condition |
Law Enforcement
The detective's request is the most complex. Most states require health care providers to report gunshot wounds to police, and the Privacy Rule permits disclosures that are required by law, limited to what the law requires. Beyond that report, the rule allows certain disclosures to law enforcement only in defined circumstances, such as providing limited identifying information to help locate a suspect or witness, responding to a court order or subpoena, or providing information about a crime victim if the victim agrees (OCR, n.d.-b). Because Mr. Reyes is a victim and is able to decide, the hospital should ask him whether he agrees to share more with the detective. If he declines, staff should give only the facts the state reporting law requires.
Family and Friends
The rule permits disclosure of information relevant to a person's involvement in the patient's care, or payment for it, when the patient is present and has capacity and does not object, or when staff can reasonably infer that he would not object. Because Mr. Reyes is awake and capable, the correct step is simply to ask him. He agreed to let his mother know his condition and declined to let his girlfriend be told anything beyond that he was admitted, and staff honored both choices. This is where confidentiality and respect for autonomy meet: the patient, not the family, decides who knows.
Employer and Media
No permission in the rule allows disclosure to an employer without authorization, so the hospital declined and suggested that Mr. Reyes provide a work note if he wishes. For the reporter, the only possible route was the facility directory, which can confirm a patient's presence and general condition to people who ask for him by name, unless the patient opts out. Given the circumstances of a shooting, Mr. Reyes asked to be excluded from the directory, so staff should neither confirm nor deny that he is a patient.
The Minimum Necessary Standard
Even when a disclosure is permitted, the covered entity must make reasonable efforts to limit it to the minimum necessary for the purpose, except for disclosures for treatment, to the patient or required by law. For the mother, that means his general condition and plan, not his full record. For the police report, it means what the state law requires, not the operative note.
If a Disclosure Goes Wrong
Suppose a unit clerk, trying to be helpful, had told the reporter that Mr. Reyes was in surgery. That would be an impermissible disclosure. Under the breach notification provisions that accompany the Privacy Rule, the hospital would have to assess the probability that the information was compromised, considering what was disclosed, to whom, whether it was actually viewed and what was done to limit it. Unless that assessment showed a low probability of compromise, the hospital would have to notify Mr. Reyes without unreasonable delay and no later than 60 days after discovery, and report the breach to the federal government. The clerk would face the hospital's sanctions policy, which the rule requires covered entities to have and apply. Naming these consequences in training helps staff understand that a friendly answer on the phone is a compliance event, not a courtesy.
The Ethical Basis of Confidentiality
The rules rest on ethical duties. Confidentiality protects patients' autonomy over their own information, prevents harms such as retaliation or stigma, and preserves the trust that makes patients willing to tell clinicians the truth (Beauchamp & Childress, 2019). For a gunshot victim, disclosure to the wrong person could expose him to further danger. Where the law requires disclosure, as with gunshot reporting, society has judged that preventing harm to others can outweigh confidentiality, but only to the extent the law requires.
Guidance for Staff
The privacy officer will give staff three rules of thumb for similar days. First, ask what purpose the request serves and which specific permission covers it; if none does, the answer is no. Second, when the patient can decide, ask the patient. Third, refer police requests beyond mandatory reports, subpoenas and media inquiries to the privacy officer or administrator on call, and document every disclosure.
Conclusion
Five requests for one patient's information show that the HIPAA Privacy Rule works through specific, narrow permissions rather than a general principle. Law enforcement received what state law required; the mother received what the patient allowed; the employer and reporter received nothing. Naming the provision behind each decision, applying the minimum necessary standard and keeping the patient at the center protects both his privacy and the hospital's compliance.
References
Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2019). Principles of biomedical ethics (8th ed.). Oxford University Press.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights. (n.d.-a). Summary of the HIPAA privacy rule. https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/laws-regulations/index.html
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights. (n.d.-b). HIPAA privacy rule: A guide for law enforcement. https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/index.html
How this IHP 420 Module 4 example is structured
The assignment is organized by request so that each disclosure limit is named precisely. It opens with the scenario and the general rule. A table then summarizes each requester, the governing provision and the decision. Separate sections explain the harder calls, law enforcement and family, and the minimum necessary standard that applies across them. The ethical basis of confidentiality follows, and the paper ends with guidance the privacy officer will give staff.
Get IHP 420 Module 4 written to your instructions
Upload the IHP 420 Module 4 assignment, the rubric and the scenario you were given. A privacy analysis naming each rule that applies comes back within 24 to 48 hours; the first is free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Southern New Hampshire University document.
IHP 420 Module 4 questions, answered
What does IHP 420 Module 4 usually cover?
Around this point, health care law and ethics courses often address confidentiality and privacy: what health information is protected, when it may be disclosed without the patient's authorization, and the ethical duties behind the rules. Assignments frequently ask students to apply the rules to specific requests.
Can a hospital tell the police about a patient?
In some circumstances. The HIPAA Privacy Rule permits disclosures required by law, such as state laws requiring gunshot wounds to be reported, and certain limited disclosures to law enforcement, such as identifying information for locating a suspect or information about a crime victim with the victim's agreement. Each situation must fit a specific permission.
What is the minimum necessary standard?
When a disclosure is permitted but not for treatment, the covered entity must make reasonable efforts to limit the information to the minimum necessary to accomplish the purpose. It prevents a lawful disclosure from becoming an excessive one.